Investigation into livestock auction market conditions
Investigation & Exposure
In Effect
February 27, 2024
Summary
On 27 February 2024, Sinergia Animal and We Animals Media published an undercover investigation documenting conditions at livestock auction markets in South America, including two Chilean fairs — Fegosa and Tattersall — and the Cañuelas Market in Argentina. Footage was collected by We Animals Media photojournalists Renata Valdivia and Molly Condit during approximately two weeks in 2022–2023 across more than 30 sites in Chile and Argentina. At the Chilean auction markets, the investigation documents weak and injured animals, overcrowding in pens, repeated hitting of animals, lack of veterinary attention, unsanitary conditions, and visible signs of disease. Sinergia Animal states that the documented practices do not conform to national and international animal welfare regulations — including Chile’s Law 20.380 and Penal Code Article 291 ter — and publicly denounces the alleged non-compliance. The investigation reports, based on a confidential source, that approximately 90% of animals sold in the documented livestock auctions are sent directly to local slaughterhouses after sale. Species documented at the Chilean markets include cattle, pigs, sheep, and horses. The investigation focuses on Fegosa and Tattersall as named facilities; it does not claim to comprehensively survey all Chilean livestock auctions. No formal enforcement actions, regulatory sanctions, or operational changes at the named markets have been documented in sources consulted as a result of the investigation.
Background Context
Before the investigation, Chile had national legislation on animal protection including Law 20.380 and Penal Code Article 291 ter, as well as SAG Decrees 28, 29, and 30 governing slaughter, industrial production, and transport — documented in a separate Development record. Separate analyses of official enforcement data indicate that between 2021 and 2024 the Chilean livestock industry accumulated hundreds of animal welfare-related infractions and sanctions based on SAG records, suggesting a pre-existing pattern of regulatory non-compliance. Sinergia Animal and We Animals Media had collaborated on investigations in Latin American farming, transport, and slaughter contexts prior to 2024. Chilean media outlets including G5Noticias and ReporteDiario republished the investigation’s findings shortly after publication. The investigation also documents conditions at the Cañuelas livestock auction in Argentina, which is outside the scope of this record; an Argentina-specific record would be required to document that component separately.
System Impact
Direction
Neutral / Administrative
Type
Exposes System
Significance
Moderate
Sinergia Animal published the investigation press release and image gallery on 27 February 2024. We Animals Media photojournalists Renata Valdivia and Molly Condit conducted the field documentation across Chile and Argentina in 2022–2023. The investigation placed images and video of conditions at Fegosa and Tattersall into the public domain, with G5Noticias and ReporteDiario amplifying findings for Chilean audiences. The press materials explicitly reference Law 20.380 and international animal welfare regulations in framing the documented conditions as alleged non-compliance. An Animal Law Focus analysis of SAG enforcement data documented hundreds of animal welfare infractions in the Chilean livestock industry between 2021 and 2024, providing a broader regulatory compliance context for the investigation’s claims. No formal enforcement actions or regulatory sanctions initiated by Chilean authorities specifically in response to the investigation are documented in sources consulted. The Fegosa and Tattersall markets’ operational status following the investigation is not specified in available sources.
Anticipated Effects
If Chilean regulatory or prosecutorial authorities use the investigation materials to initiate inspections or administrative or criminal proceedings, the development would be expected to result in increased scrutiny of the named markets and their handling practices.
If auction operators respond to public pressure or enforcement attention by modifying handling protocols, infrastructure, or veterinary oversight, the investigation could conditionally alter on-site practices at Chilean livestock auctions.
Whether the investigation produces measurable changes in animal welfare conditions at Chilean auction markets or in the volume of animals processed through them is not established in available sources.
Significance Rationale
Assigned Neutral / Administrative (impact direction) because the investigation discloses conditions at specific livestock auction markets in Chile but has produced no documented changes in animal numbers, facility closures, enforcement actions, or operational modifications attributable to the investigation in sources consulted.
Assigned Exposes System (impact type) because the primary mechanism is capturing and publishing photo and video evidence of conditions at named livestock auction markets — Fegosa and Tattersall — placing previously non-public visual and narrative information about their operational conditions into the public domain and connecting those conditions to existing regulatory frameworks.
Assigned Moderate significance because the investigation documents conditions at two named Chilean auction markets reported to handle thousands of animals, with an estimated 90% flowing directly to slaughterhouses — documenting a specific recurring supply chain node within Chilean meat production. The scope is limited to a subset of national auction markets rather than the whole system.
Impact direction is Neutral / Administrative; the trajectory sentence is not applicable.
Key Actors
Sinergia Animal (international animal protection NGO) coordinated and published the investigation. We Animals Media (photojournalism organisation) provided field documentation through photojournalists Renata Valdivia and Molly Condit. Fegosa and Tattersall livestock auction fairs in Chile are the named investigated facilities. SAG is the Chilean governmental body responsible for enforcing animal welfare regulations in the livestock sector. The Ministerio Público (Public Prosecutor’s Office), Carabineros de Chile, and Policía de Investigaciones are the entities competent to receive complaints based on photographic and video evidence.
Notice an inaccuracy or omission?
If you believe information on this page is incorrect, incomplete, or missing important context, you may submit a suggested correction for review.