Germany 2021 – ban on subcontracting in meat industry
Law & Regulation
In Effect
January 1, 2021
Summary
On 1 January 2021, the core provisions of the Arbeitsschutzkontrollgesetz (Gesetz zur Verbesserung des Vollzugs im Arbeitsschutz) entered into force following adoption by the Bundestag and Bundesrat on 22 December 2020 and promulgation in the Bundesgesetzblatt on 30 December 2020. The law prohibits the use of subcontracting via Werkverträge for core activities — including slaughtering and cutting — in meat industry companies above the craft-butcher threshold (more than 49 workers) from 1 January 2021. The use of temporary agency workers (Leiharbeit) in these core areas was largely prohibited from 1 April 2021, with a transitional exception allowing limited agency work in meat processing under collective agreements, phasing to full prohibition from 1 April 2024. The law also mandates electronic recording of working time, sets minimum inspection frequencies for occupational safety authorities, raises maximum fines for violations, and establishes minimum standards for company-provided worker accommodation. Several meat industry companies filed urgent applications with the Federal Constitutional Court seeking to prevent the law from entering into force; these did not succeed.
Background Context
Before the law, Germany’s meat industry relied extensively on subcontracting arrangements (Werkverträge) and temporary agency work for core production tasks such as slaughtering and cutting, with many workers being EU migrant workers, particularly from Romania and Bulgaria. COVID-19 outbreaks in German slaughterhouses in 2020 — documented at facilities including the Tönnies plant in Rheda-Wiedenbrück — exposed working and living conditions, generating sustained political and public attention. The NGG trade union (Gewerkschaft Nahrung-Genuss-Gaststätten) had campaigned for years for legislative intervention on subcontracting practices. The Federal Ministry of Labour and Social Affairs (BMAS) drafted the law; the Federal Cabinet adopted the draft on 28 July 2020. An earlier statute, the Gesetz zur Sicherung von Arbeitnehmerrechten in der Fleischwirtschaft (GSA Fleisch, 2017), had already targeted employment practices in the sector; the Arbeitsschutzkontrollgesetz builds on and further amends that statute.
System Impact
Direction
Neutral / Administrative
Type
Alters Legal Basis
Significance
Moderate
From 1 January 2021, subcontracting via Werkverträge for core slaughter and cutting activities in German meat industry companies above the 49-worker threshold became legally prohibited. From 1 April 2021, the use of temporary agency workers in these core areas was largely prohibited, with a transitional exception allowing limited agency work (up to 8% of the workforce, maximum four-month assignments) in meat processing under a collective agreement. From 1 April 2024, the transitional exception expired and agency work in core meat production activities became fully prohibited. Major meat groups were required to bring formerly subcontracted and agency workers into direct employment relationships. The law also established mandatory electronic working-time recording for meat sector workers, set minimum inspection frequency requirements for Länder occupational safety authorities, increased maximum administrative fines for violations, and specified minimum standards for company-provided accommodation. Trade union and academic analyses document that, following the law’s entry into force, trade unions found new organising opportunities and negotiated collective agreements at company and industry level. No evidence of core provision repeal or suspension has been identified in sources through 2025.
Anticipated Effects
If the prohibition on Werkverträge and Leiharbeit in core meat production activities is maintained and enforced consistently, the employment structure of large German meat plants would continue to operate on the basis of direct employment for slaughtering and cutting functions, removing the legal basis for the contracting arrangements that had previously characterised the sector.
If the mandatory inspection frequency and elevated fines alter enforcement patterns, occupational safety compliance in German slaughter and processing facilities would be expected to increase, reducing the incidence of working-condition violations documented in the COVID-19 outbreak context.
Whether the restructuring of employment arrangements has affected or will affect slaughter throughput volumes, production costs, or the competitive position of German meat plants relative to facilities in other EU member states is not established in sources consulted.
Significance Rationale
Assigned Neutral / Administrative (impact direction) because the law restructures employment and enforcement conditions within the German meat sector — prohibiting subcontracting and phasing out temporary agency work in core production activities — without directly prohibiting slaughter or reducing the number of animals processed. Available sources document changes in labour arrangements and compliance systems; no documented contraction in slaughter volumes or animal throughput attributable to the law is identified in sources consulted.
Assigned Alters Legal Basis (impact type) because the primary mechanism is the statutory prohibition on previously lawful contracting arrangements — Werkverträge and Leiharbeit — in core meat production activities. The law changes what is legally permitted regarding employment structures in facilities where slaughter and meat processing occur. Modifies Conditions is a secondary mechanism: by mandating direct employment, working-time recording, inspection standards, and accommodation rules, the law modifies the regulatory and employment conditions within the existing meat production system.
Assigned Moderate significance because the law applies nationwide to core employment arrangements in large-scale German meat facilities — the major integrated meat groups including Tönnies, Westfleisch, Vion, and Danish Crown — and triggers structural changes in employment, compliance, and union organising. The significance operates at the labour and enforcement layer of the exploitation system rather than at the animal-numbers layer; no production-scale contraction is documented.
Impact direction is Neutral / Administrative; the trajectory sentence is not applicable.
Key Actors
The Bundestag and Bundesrat adopted the Arbeitsschutzkontrollgesetz on 22 December 2020. The Federal Ministry of Labour and Social Affairs (BMAS) drafted and promoted the law; the Federal Cabinet adopted the draft on 28 July 2020. Major meat groups subject to the provisions include Tönnies, Westfleisch, Vion, and Danish Crown, along with other meat industry companies above the 49-worker threshold. The NGG (Gewerkschaft Nahrung-Genuss-Gaststätten) trade union was a central campaigning actor and beneficiary of the organising opportunities the law created. Länder occupational safety authorities and customs authorities (Zoll) are the primary enforcement bodies. Several unnamed meat industry companies filed urgent constitutional complaints; these did not prevent the law from entering into force.
Editorial Correction Notice
Affected animals: No Animals CPT records are assigned. The Arbeitsschutzkontrollgesetz is a labour law that regulates employment arrangements in meat processing facilities; it does not directly regulate the treatment, numbers, or conditions of the animals processed. Pigs, cattle, and chickens are processed in the regulated facilities but are not the subject of the law’s provisions. Assigning animal CPT records here would imply a direct regulatory relationship between the law and specific species that does not exist. As the database expands and cross-record analysis tools are developed, the connection between this labour law record and the German meat production system can be made through the Slaughter practice record and the Meat industry record without requiring direct animal assignments here.
Development date: Set to 1 January 2021 — the date the core subcontracting prohibition entered into force. The adoption date (22 December 2020) and promulgation date (30 December 2020) are documented in Background Context. Subsequent staged provisions (1 April 2021, 1 April 2024) are documented in System Impact Description.
Scale & Prevalence: No quantified data on the number of plants, workers, or animals affected by the subcontracting and agency work bans are available in sources consulted. Secondary analyses describe the law as covering the major German meat groups but provide qualitative rather than audited statistical assessments of coverage.
Key Actors — constitutional complaints: The specific companies that filed urgent applications with the Federal Constitutional Court are not named in English-language summaries of the constitutional complaints. German-language legal reporting would identify the named applicants.
Notice an inaccuracy or omission?
If you believe information on this page is incorrect, incomplete, or missing important context, you may submit a suggested correction for review.